Ritual Dissent Method

Ritual Dissent Method

From Learning and training wiki

Share/Save/Bookmark
Revision as of 12:37, 30 November 2009 by Marco.perone (Talk | contribs)

Jump to: navigation, search
Term2.png RITUAL DISSENT METHOD
Workshop method designed to test and enhance proposals, plans, stories and ideas by subjecting them to a “ritualized” dissent (challenge) or assent (positive proposals). It allows assessing ideas and challenging the participants to think for significant improvement opportunities. The Ritual Dissent is a forced listening technique with no dialogue or discourse with the purpose of encouraging participants to find and improve ideas and proposals through a disagreement and discord based technique. It can be used on its own or linked to Story Construction, Social Construction of the Cynefin Framework, and a broad range of methods.

The technique is generally used in a workshop with a minimum of three groups and at least three participants in each to obtain more iterations and diversity (ideally the number of participants should not be higher than a dozen).

The basic approach involves a spokesperson for each group presenting his idea or plan to one group who listen to him in silence. After the presentation, the spokesperson turns his chair facing the back to the audience in order to avoid any eye contact and listen in silence while the group critically attacks (dissent) or provide alternatives (assent). The approach of not facing the audience de-personalizes any dissent to the proposal so that the meaning of the attack is not a personal one to the presenter, but is critically to refine the proposal. [1]


Toolkit.png Teleconference Clock Method

Contents

Preparing a Teleconference Clock

  1. Have an agenda that includes conference goals and participant expectations. Don’t forget to consider their time zones when scheduling.
  2. Consider the impact of comments volume (based on the number of participants) with the available time.
  3. Send all participants the dial-in number and pass-codes if needed. With international groups, be clear if the number is cost-free.
  4. Distribute supporting documents or files before the beginning of the conference call.
  5. Take care in advance of the call controls. If the leader controls the start/stop of the call and may have to leave early, have a second person with leader privileges in order to avoid call interruptions.
  6. Greet and know who is online (use the “clock" method for the introduction of each participant).
  7. Ask participants to review the agenda prior to the call.

Step by Step

  1. Ask every participant to get a piece of paper to draw a circle on it and mark the hours like a clock.
  2. Assign each person a spot on the “clock” when joining the conference call. The first person on the call put his name on 1 o’clock hour, the second 2, etc. If there are more than twelve people, start adding 1:30, 2:30 etc.
  3. Use the “clock order” to create a speaking sequence and to ensure everyone speaks. Participants can make notations and use the piece of paper as a visual tool to match names, voices and inputs.
  4. Vary the position of the participants on the clock if you are planning a multiple rounds of speaking.
  5. Use some form of feedback or evaluation for improving possible later calls. An "after action review" can be done at the conclusion of the call or by post-call emails.
  6. Ask each participant to describe with three adjectives their “clock” experience.

General Call Etiquette

  1. Call from a quiet location.
  2. Avoid cell phones and speakerphones. If you use them, remember to put the mute button when not talking.
  3. Use quality headsets to avoid metallic sounds.
  4. Avoid paper rustling.
  5. Caution with multitasking; some is unavoidable, but remind people about attention and occasionally call for a moment of silence to keep their attention.
  6. Consider a kind treatment of bodies: on long calls, offer short breaks.
  7. Speak clearly and slow down if you are a "fast talker".
  8. Be enthusiastic and use a tone appropriate to the group. Once you start talking, the first impression is important.
  9. Vary voice tone (avoid monotone presentation).


Job Aid

Pdf.pngUsing Teleconference Clock



References

  1. [1] (30 November 2009),[2] (30 November 2009), [3] (30 November 2009)